Exhalation by Ted Chiang Sunday Book Circle - Part I
Exhalation is a collection of short stories by Ted Chiang, the author of the story that Arrival is based on. These stories are very intellectual and sometimes even staid in their delivery. Chiang often breaks away from the characters of the stories to give information about the science fiction element along with the scientific community’s research or the general population’s response. But almost every story is thematically focused on something philosophical or humanist.
The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate works like an Arabian Nights story. It is being told to someone and includes other stories told to the person telling the story. I have started Arabian Nights recently, and it will take me a while to finish it, but Chiang captures the structure well. He apes the style of the Richard Burton translation to such an extent that I think I may end up confusing The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate for an actual Arabian Nights story sometime in the future. Thematically the story seems focused on the idea of dwelling on the past or undercutting your future, all with the idea that you cannot change your own nature. This is a surprising story to start the anthology on because it doesn’t feel at all like modern sci-fi. It is, however, one of the better time travel stories I’ve experienced because any time travel done has always been done. It’s a loop and I hate time travel where you can change the past. It seems like a cheat whenever a story has the past change. This is an unusual story, but it is also very sweet.
Exhalation, the title story, is about a completely different world wherein all the people are clockwork and run on air, as such they are mostly immortal unless they run out of air. The main character does what no one has been able to do before and see a functional brain, his own. He discovers that not only do their brains work on air, but on differing air pressure, and the pressure in their world is equalizing. One day all of them will die. This is such a weird story. I like the world it creates, but I’m not sure how I feel about the outcomes. I do appreciate that for the most part the equalizing is out of their control. While their use of air is causing the equalization, it would seem weird to blame them for the coming end because the only other choice is non-existence. They cannot help the way they function. There’s nothing to suggest that they made themselves this way since they didn’t even know it. The main character is hopeful that another society of people exists outside their world and that’s why he’s writing his account. And most of Chiang’s stories end in hopefulness, even though some of that hope is pointless.
Become a Supporter for the rest of the review!